Build my own list
If you liked

Reaper

2007–2009 · 2 seasons · The CW

New and upcoming (2026 and later)

Out this year, or not out yet.

Coven Academy

2026 · 1 season · Freeform
supernatural
Not streaming in the USNext episode 2026-10-01
My Royal NemesisMy Royal Nemesis

The last five years (2021 to 2025)

Current, and all of it watchable now.

Debris

2021 · 1 season · NBC
The Roku Channel
The AcolyteThe AcolyteCallsCallsThe SwarmThe SwarmParallelsParallelsAgatha All AlongAgatha All AlongThe Judge from HellThe Judge from HellGoosebumpsGoosebumps

Five to fifteen years back (2011 to 2020)

Recent enough that everyone can still find it, old enough to be finished.

South of Hell

2015 · 1 season · WE tv
Amazon Prime VideoThe Roku ChannelThe CW
The WhispersThe WhispersThe Secret CircleThe Secret CircleZero HourZero HourKevin (Probably) Saves the WorldKevin (Probably) Saves the WorldCharmedCharmedProofProofNEXTNEXT

Older than fifteen years (before 2011)

The back catalogue, where the closest match often is.

Moonlight

2007–2008 · 1 season · CBS
The Roku ChannelHooplaPlex
Early EditionEarly EditionTakenTakenThe Dead ZoneThe Dead ZoneJohn DoeJohn DoeThe GatesThe GatesHexHexSurfaceSurface

Want this tuned to you?

Name three shows you loved and it ranks the whole catalogue against your taste rather than against one title.

Build my list