Build my own list
If you liked

America's Most Wanted

1988–2012 · 15 seasons · FOX

New and upcoming (2026 and later)

Out this year, or not out yet.

Should I Marry a Murderer?

2026 · 1 season · Netflix
NetflixNetflix Standard with Ads
Gold LandGold LandTrust Me: The False ProphetTrust Me: The False Prophet

The last five years (2021 to 2025)

Current, and all of it watchable now.

Monsters Inside: The 24 Faces of Billy Milligan

2021 · 1 season · Netflix
NetflixNetflix Standard with Ads
Gloria Trevi: Ellas soy yoGloria Trevi: Ellas soy yoHeistHeistThe Curious Case of Natalia GraceThe Curious Case of Natalia GraceNight Stalker: The Hunt for a Serial KillerNight Stalker: The Hunt for a Serial KillerAmerican NightmareAmerican NightmareWorst Roommate EverWorst Roommate EverThis Is a Robbery: The World's Biggest Art HeistThis Is a Robbery: The World's Biggest Art Heist

Five to fifteen years back (2011 to 2020)

Recent enough that everyone can still find it, old enough to be finished.

McMillion$

2020 · 1 season · HBO
HBO Max Amazon ChannelYouTube TVHBO Max
En la Boca del LoboEn la Boca del LoboHomicide Hunter: Lt Joe KendaHomicide Hunter: Lt Joe KendaThe VowThe VowThe PharmacistThe PharmacistRottenRottenThe Disappearance of Madeleine McCannThe Disappearance of Madeleine McCannDirty MoneyDirty Money

Older than fifteen years (before 2011)

The back catalogue, where the closest match often is.

The Staircase

2004–2018 · 1 season · SundanceTV
NetflixNetflix Standard with Ads
The First 48The First 48Seven Deadly SinsSeven Deadly SinsUnsolved MysteriesUnsolved MysteriesAuschwitz: The Nazis and the Final SolutionAuschwitz: The Nazis and the Final Solution1000 Ways to Die1000 Ways to DieGreat PerformancesGreat PerformancesFrontlineFrontline

Want this tuned to you?

Name three shows you loved and it ranks the whole catalogue against your taste rather than against one title.

Build my list